We counted at the very least 16 false or deceptive claims within the prolonged footage Trump posted, 10 of them pandemic-related. Under is the complete listing. We have famous the situations through which the Trump quote we’re checking is from the prolonged footage the President posted moderately than the footage televised by CBS.

Trump claimed that coronavirus circumstances are rising merely “as a result of we’re doing a lot testing.”

“If we did not do testing, circumstances could be means down,” he added within the prolonged footage.

Details First: It is not true that the US is just seeing an increase in cases as a result of the variety of checks has elevated. Trump additionally used this refrain throughout earlier spikes within the variety of circumstances; it was additionally false then.
Whereas the variety of each day checks has certainly been rising, there isn’t any doubt there was a rise within the precise unfold of the virus, not simply that extra circumstances are being captured. One telltale signal is that hospitalizations are additionally rising, setting records in some states. Additionally, the proportion of US checks coming again constructive has also been rising since late September. And deaths have started to rise again, too, after the standard lag following the spike in circumstances.

“The nook”

Stahl identified that folks can see for themselves that it is not true when he repeatedly claims we now have “turned the nook” on the pandemic and that it’s “disappearing.” Trump responded, “That is proper, we now have turned the nook.”
Details First: Stahl was proper, Trump was mistaken. Once more, US pandemic numbers — newly confirmed cases, hospitalizations, the take a look at positivity price, deaths — are all getting worse, not higher. There’s simply no foundation for his obscure declare that we’re rounding some type of nook in a constructive course.

Trump’s feedback about Fauci

Stahl mentioned, “You referred to as Dr. Fauci and different well being officers idiots.” Trump responded, “The place did I name him an fool?”

Details First: This was deceptive at finest. On a telephone name with marketing campaign employees on Monday, with reporters from CNN and different shops listening in, Trump said, “Individuals are uninterested in listening to Fauci and these idiots, all these idiots who acquired it mistaken.”

Trump might maybe make an argument that he was distinguishing Dr. Anthony Fauci from the unnamed “these idiots” he was referring to, however that is a stretch. (And Trump went on to inform Stahl that Fauci has “been mistaken lots,” which is how he was defining “idiots” within the telephone name.)

Trump rallies and masks

Stahl advised Trump that she could not consider that, after so many individuals who attended his White Home occasion for Supreme Court docket nominee Amy Coney Barrett in September acquired sick with the coronavirus, Trump nonetheless would not strongly encourage his rally attendees to put on masks.

Trump appropriately famous that masks are handed out on the rallies. However he additionally mentioned within the prolonged footage, “Nicely, have you ever been trying? Yesterday, check out, uh, have a look yesterday in Arizona. All people behind me had a masks.” When she talked about his Wisconsin rally, Trump mentioned, “Lots of people had masks and it was exterior.”

Details First: Trump’s feedback had been deceptive. A big proportion of the individuals at his two Arizona rallies final Monday and at his most up-to-date Wisconsin rally, in Janesville final Saturday, weren’t sporting masks. And it is an exaggeration to say that “all people” standing behind him in Arizona was sporting a masks; most of these individuals had been, however some weren’t.

Reporters who cowl Trump rallies additionally famous that there’s usually extra mask-wearing among the many individuals standing behind him, who can be on digicam as he speaks, than there’s in the remainder of the group.

Trump and a “lock her up” chant

Trump repeatedly denied that he had endorsed the thought of locking up Democratic Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer. He mentioned within the prolonged footage, “When did I say lock her up? When did I say lock up the governor? I by no means mentioned lock up the governor.” After some back-and-forth with Stahl, which aired within the televised model, he mentioned, “Lesley, that is such a vicious factor you simply mentioned. I did not say lock up the governor of Michigan. I might by no means say that. Why would I say that?”

Details First: This was extremely deceptive. At Trump’s rally in Michigan final Saturday, his criticism of Whitmer prompted the group to chant “lock her up.” He interjected in the course of the chant to say, “Lock ’em all up.”

So whereas he didn’t explicitly say the phrases “lock up the governor of Michigan,” he at the very least strongly recommended that he was endorsing the thought.

Whitmer and a lockdown

Trump claimed of Whitmer, “They don’t seem to be liking her a lot trigger she’s acquired all people locked down.”

Details First: That is not true. Whereas Whitmer nonetheless has some vital pandemic-related restrictions, she will not be at present imposing something that may pretty be described as a “lockdown.” Whitmer lifted her stay-at-home order on June 1.
The Detroit Free Press published a helpful rundown on what occurred subsequent: “Bars and eating places throughout the state reopened shortly after the order was lifted adopted by barbershops, spas and hair and nail salons in mid-June. Casinos in Detroit had been allowed to reopen in early August. Colleges throughout the state reopened this fall for in-person studying. And Whitmer allowed gyms to reopen in early September and film theaters and bowling alleys to reopen in early October.”
There are nonetheless capability limits on numerous sorts of Michigan institutions. For instance, eating places and bars are capped at 50% of the standard restrict for indoor seating.
Earlier in October, Michigan’s Supreme Court docket struck down as unconstitutional an emergency regulation from 1945 that Whitmer had relied on to impose pandemic orders. However her administration then imposed similar orders below the state’s public well being code.

Coronavirus restrictions in Pennsylvania and North Carolina

Within the prolonged footage, Trump additionally accused the Democratic governors of Pennsylvania and North Carolina of imposing a lockdown on their residents.

Details First: Neither state is locked down.

Since July 3, all 67 counties in Pennsylvania have been within the third stage, “inexperienced,” of Gov. Tom Wolf’s three-stage pandemic plan. The inexperienced part consists of vital restrictions on many companies — similar to 50% occupancy limits for bars, eating places, barbershops, gyms and malls — however these companies are up and operating, not shut down.

And college districts are permitted to determine for themselves whether or not to have in-school or distant instruction.

North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper moved the state to “Section 3” on October 2, easing his earlier restrictions.
There are, as in different states, restrictions still in effect. Mass gatherings are restricted to 25 individuals indoors and 50 individuals open air; eating places are limited to 50% capability; bars are restricted to 30% out of doors capability or 100 individuals, whichever is much less; gyms are limited to 30% capability. Nevertheless it’s inaccurate to name this a lockdown.

“The Governor has applied a dimmer change method to easing restrictions responsibly that enables individuals to get again to work and transfer our economic system ahead whereas conserving individuals protected,” press secretary Dory MacMillan mentioned in an electronic mail.

Job creation

Trump boasted about what he described as report job creation of 11.4 million jobs within the final 5 months.

Details First: That is deceptive. Whereas it is true that the 11.4 million jobs added over 5 months is a report, Trump neglected the truth that there was a a lot bigger report lack of about 22.2 million jobs over the 2 months prior. In different phrases, as of August, the nation was nonetheless down greater than 10.7 million jobs since March. (And as of September, the economic system was down about 3.9 million jobs because the starting of Trump’s presidency.)
Additionally, lots of the 11.4 million jobs “added” since Might merely signify individuals returning to their earlier jobs, from which they’d been quickly laid off. And the tempo of the roles restoration slowed significantly in September, with 661,000 jobs added — down from about 1.5 million in August.

A dying estimate

Defending his dealing with of the pandemic, Trump, within the prolonged footage, repeated his false declare that “2.2 million individuals had been purported to die.”

Details First: Trump wrongly described this 2.2 million statistic.

Trump was possible citing a report revealed in March by students from the Imperial Faculty in London that predicted {that a} complete of two.2 million Individuals might die from Covid-19 if no preventative measures had been taken by any US authorities or particular person to attempt to cease the unfold of the virus.

In different phrases, this determine was an excessive, worst-case situation if the authorities did completely nothing to deal with the virus, not an expectation.

Trump’s journey restrictions

Within the prolonged footage, Trump once more mentioned of his journey restrictions on China and Europe: “I closed it very early from China, closely contaminated, and even from Europe, closely contaminated.”

Details First: Trump was exaggerating. Whereas Trump did limit journey from China and from much of Europe, neither coverage was an precise “ban.” Each insurance policies made exemptions for journey by US residents, everlasting residents, lots of the relations of each teams, and a few others — and the restrictions on Europe exempted complete European international locations.
The New York Occasions reported April 4 that almost 40,000 individuals had flown to the US from China because the restrictions went into impact in early February.

Biden and well being care

Trump claimed within the prolonged footage that, below a Biden administration, “180 million individuals will lose their well being care” from personal insurers.

Details First: That is false. Former Vice President Joe Biden has been a vocal opponent of the “Medicare for All” single-payer proposals that will get rid of most personal insurance policy. The truth is, Biden and Sen. Bernie Sanders, a number one proponent of single-payer well being care, clashed repeatedly on the problem in the course of the Democratic major. Biden is proposing a “public possibility” that will permit individuals to voluntarily transfer to a Medicare-style authorities program.
It is possible that, over time, a well-liked public possibility would have an effect on personal insurers’ willingness to supply some personal plans. However Trump is suggesting Biden is actively proposing to wipe out personal insurance coverage, and that is not the case in any respect.

The person mandate

Trump boasted within the prolonged footage about how he “terminated” Obamacare’s particular person mandate, saying that this “truly makes Obamacare not Obamacare.” He continued, “So Obamacare basically was terminated, as we all know it. Now we now have the carcass of Obamacare.”

Details First: That is false. The person mandate, which required Individuals to acquire medical health insurance, was certainly a key a part of Obamacare — however key elements of the regulation stay in impact. For instance, Trump has not eradicated Obamacare’s protections for individuals with pre-existing circumstances, its growth of the Medicaid insurance coverage program for low-income individuals, the federal and state marketplaces that permit individuals to buy protection, or the buyer subsidies that assist lots of them make the purchases.

As well as, Trump has not actually eradicated the mandate. Moderately, in his 2017 tax overhaul, he decreased the penalty for violating the mandate to $0. This may appear pedantic, however the existence of a tax penalty that doesn’t increase any income is a central issue in the legal case through which Trump’s administration is making an attempt to get the Supreme Court docket to strike down everything of Obamacare as unconstitutional.

Trump’s well being care plan

Trump promised, as he has prior to now, that he’ll introduce an excellent well being care plan to switch Obamacare, which he’s making an attempt to get the courts to invalidate. When Stahl requested why we have not seen this plan, Trump mentioned within the prolonged footage, “You might have seen it. I have been placing out items far and wide.”

Details First: That is false. As Trump acknowledged at different moments of the interview, he has not but launched a plan.

Searching for to guarantee Individuals who profit from Obamacare’s protections for individuals with pre-existing circumstances, Trump signed an government order in September declaring that it’s US coverage “to make sure that Individuals with pre-existing circumstances can receive the insurance coverage of their alternative at reasonably priced charges.” However this order does not have any practical force. And the well being care “imaginative and prescient” he introduced in September, through which he laid out different broad rules, can also be not even near a complete plan.

Biden and the suburbs

Trump claimed within the prolonged footage, “I am saving suburbia. He is gonna destroy suburbia. He is acquired a regulation, which I terminated, that he would put again, and even worse, that may destroy — that may carry low-income housing tasks into suburbia.”

Details First: Trump was exaggerating once more. The Obama-era regulation Trump was referring to wouldn’t destroy the suburbs; the rule, often called Affirmatively Furthering Truthful Housing, is an replace to a decades-old federal requirement aimed to get rid of discrimination and fight segregation in housing. It doesn’t mandate low-income housing to be inbuilt suburban areas.

Trump’s plea to suburban girls

Stahl advised Trump, “You mentioned the opposite day to suburban girls, ‘Will you please like me? Please?” She used a pleading tone of voice in repeating Trump’s remark.

Trump responded, “Oh, I did not say that. You understand, that is so deceptive the best way — I say jokingly, ‘Suburban girls, you must love me as a result of I am providing you with safety. And I removed the worst regulation.'” He repeated that he had made the remark “kiddingly,” not as if he was “begging.”

Details First: Stahl did exaggerate in her tone — Trump did not make this October 13 comment in fairly such a sad-sack voice — however there was no indication Trump was kidding on the time.

He mentioned at a rally in Pennsylvania: “So can I ask you to do me a favor. Suburban girls, will you please like me?” The group cheered, and Trump mentioned, “Please. Please.” You may watch the clip here.
Trump has a history of claiming that his previous critical remarks had been mere jokes or sarcasm.

Obama, Biden and spying

After Stahl requested Trump if he desires to lock up former President Barack Obama, Trump mentioned within the prolonged footage, “No, I do not wanna lock him up, however he spied on my marketing campaign. Obama and Biden spied on my marketing campaign.”

Details First: That is baseless. There’s no evidence Biden or Obama had any private position in ordering the FBI surveillance of Trump’s marketing campaign, which got here as a part of its investigation of the marketing campaign’s relationship with Russia.

Source link


0 0 vote
Article Rating
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x